Can You Use Customer Reviews and Photos Without Permission? (The Legality of Testimonials)

Can You Use Customer Reviews and Photos Without Permission? (The Legality of Testimonials)

A customer leaves a glowing 5-star review on your store. They attach a mirror selfie in your dress, or a before-and-after photo showing how clear their skin looks after two weeks with your serum.

It's marketing gold.

Your first instinct is to screenshot it for Instagram, add the photo to your product page, or turn the before-and-after into a paid Meta ad. They shared it publicly and praised your brand, so you can reuse it, right?

Usually not, at least not beyond the review widget where they posted it. Repurposing customer content without clear permission can lead to copyright and right of publicity claims, and testimonials in ads also come with FTC rules.

Here's where the legal lines are, and how a simple release form protects your social proof.

1. The Right of Publicity: You Can't Commercialize Someone's Face for Free

Most states give people the right to control how their name, image, voice, and likeness are used for commercial purposes.

When a customer posts a photo in a review or tags your brand on social media, they're sharing feedback. They haven't agreed to become the face of your ads.

Using their face, name or recognizable likeness in any of these is commercial use:

  • A paid Facebook, Instagram or TikTok ad
  • A marketing email to your subscriber list
  • A promotional banner on your website
  • A printed catalog or wholesale pitch deck

Without their consent, you're taking a real risk. Depending on the state, the customer could seek damages, send a demand letter, or force you to pull an ad you spent weeks optimizing. Some states, like New York, require that consent be in writing, and written consent is the safest approach everywhere.

2. The Copyright Problem: Who Owns the Picture?

There's also a copyright issue: the person who takes a photo owns the copyright. Even though the photo features your product, it doesn't belong to you.

That person isn't always your customer. A mirror selfie belongs to the customer, but if a friend snapped the photo, the friend owns it. That's why a good release asks the customer to confirm they took the photo or have the right to share it.

Copying a customer's photo from a review platform or their social media and reusing it in your marketing without permission can be copyright infringement.

Your review app's terms matter here too. Many apps let you display reviews in your on-site widget, and some offer consent options for broader marketing use. But terms vary by app and change often, so check what yours covers, and what customers agreed to when they submitted, before using review photos anywhere else, especially in paid ads.

3. Handle With Extra Care: Before-and-Afters and Minors

If you sell beauty, wellness, fitness, or apparel, some customer content carries extra risk.

Before-and-after photos

Photos showing acne, weight changes, hair thinning, or body transformations are personal. A customer who's comfortable sharing them in a review may be mortified to see them in an ad shown to thousands of strangers. Get specific consent for this kind of use.

Before-and-afters also raise FTC issues. They're testimonials about results, so:

  • Typical results: if the result isn't what customers can generally expect, your ad needs to clearly disclose what results people typically get.
  • Proof: claims about skin, weight, hair, or health need evidence to back them up.
  • No retouching: editing a before-and-after photo makes it misleading.

Photos of minors

Don't use photos or videos featuring children or teens without a signed release from a parent or legal guardian. Watch for customers who may be minors themselves, since a minor's own signature on a release isn't reliable. Collecting photos or other personal information from children under 13 online also raises additional issues under federal children's privacy law (COPPA).

4. The FTC's Rules on Reviews and Testimonials

Once a customer review becomes part of your marketing, FTC rules apply, and the brand is responsible for following them:

  • Keep it honest. You can fix typos, but you can't edit a testimonial in a way that changes its meaning or misrepresents the customer's experience.
  • Keep it current. Use a testimonial only as long as you have good reason to believe the customer still feels that way, and the product hasn't materially changed.
  • Disclose connections. If you gave the customer something of value, like a gift card or free product, consider whether to disclose that connection in the ad.
  • No fake or filtered reviews. The FTC's 2024 Rule on Consumer Reviews and Testimonials bans fake reviews, suppressing negative reviews, and offering incentives conditioned on a positive review.

5. How to Turn Customer Reviews into Ads the Right Way

You don't have to avoid customer content. You just need a simple process.

Step 1: Don't rely on informal DMs

A quick "Love this! Can we share?" DM answered with a thumbs-up emoji is better than nothing, but it leaves big gaps. It doesn't cover whether you can run paid ads, how long you can use the content, or whether you can edit it.

Step 2: Use a clear release form

When a customer shares a standout photo or video you want to use in your marketing, send them a simple, plain-English testimonial and likeness release. A good release covers:

  • Likeness rights: permission to use their name, photo, voice, and quote in marketing, including paid ads.
  • Copyright permission: a license to display, crop, format, and share the photo or video, plus their confirmation that they took it or have the right to share it.
  • Honesty: their confirmation that the review reflects their genuine experience.
  • Lasting permission: terms making the permission irrevocable for the agreed use, so they can't pull it after you've invested in an ad.

Step 3: Offer a thank-you

Customers are often thrilled to be featured. Offering a small thank-you, like a $25 gift card or a free product, builds goodwill and helps you get the release signed quickly. It also helps legally: giving something of value in exchange makes it easier to make the permission irrevocable.

Just make sure the thank-you is for the usage rights, not for leaving a positive review. And consider whether to disclose it in any ad that uses their content.

Key Takeaways for E-Commerce Founders

  • Public reviews aren't public domain. A review posted online isn't a license to use it in your marketing.
  • Widget display and paid ads are different. Showing a review in your store's review widget is usually covered by your review app's terms. Using it in paid ads typically requires the customer's explicit permission.
  • Get a written release for your best assets. Before you put ad spend behind a standout review, video, or before-and-after, get a signed release.
  • Follow the FTC rules. Keep testimonials accurate and current, disclose connections, and never tie incentives to positive reviews.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I quote a customer's 5-star text review without asking?

Showing a short text review with a first name and last initial (for example, "Best activewear set I've ever owned! — Sarah M.") on your product page is common and generally low risk, especially through your review app. But once you add their full name, photo, or video to a paid ad, get a written release.

Can I repost a customer's Instagram story if they tag my brand?

Resharing a story that mentions your brand using Instagram's built-in feature is standard and allowed under the platform's terms. But downloading the video, editing it, and running it as a paid ad goes beyond that, and you'll need the customer's permission in writing.

Protect Your Social Proof with Dream Shop

Don't let an avoidable privacy or copyright dispute force you to pull your best-performing ads.

Get the rights to your customer review photos, video testimonials, and written reviews with our attorney-drafted Testimonial Release Form. 

About Dream Shop: Dream Shop is an online legal education platform and template shop providing attorney-drafted contract templates, legal resources, and compliance guides tailored for e-commerce brands, digital shop owners, and content creators. We bridge the gap between generic free templates and expensive law firms to help entrepreneurs protect their businesses with confidence. 

Disclaimer: This article is for educational and informational purposes and isn't personalized legal advice. Accessing Dream Shop content and contract templates doesn't create an attorney-client relationship. For high-stakes situations, have a local attorney review your customized contract.

 

Back to blog
  • Blog post

    Give your customers a summary of your blog post

    Blog post

    Give your customers a summary of your blog post

  • Blog post

    Give your customers a summary of your blog post

    Blog post

    Give your customers a summary of your blog post

1 of 2